Illustration de l'article

A free review system

You can leave your review on any place on cartes.app. To make this system work, rather than reinventing the wheel, we use Bluesky's open network, called the Atmosphere. Find out why.

publié le , mis à jour

Being able to leave reviews and read them is a key feature for competing with Google Maps, just like Google Street View street photos.

Since October 2025, we have launched a review system. Today, we are publishing version 2.

Right now, you can write a review on any place. You can share your photos too

Building together

For street photos, a free alternative already existed and had real momentum: Panoramax. Since we integrated it into cartes.app, the Côte-d'Or department has mapped all its roads, finally offering a sovereign alternative to its citizens.

We couldn't find a free review system that had achieved Panoramax's level of success — it already counts 100 million photos. By free, we mean they are not owned by a company: anyone can contribute (just like on Google), but anyone can also download them and use them on their own site. So reviews published on cartes.app must be displayable on Comaps or on Mappy (which is not the case with Google).

Projects like Mangrove reviews exist but didn't convince us because of the chicken-and-egg problem: creating a new database from scratch means having to cold-start it. The same problem affects the other project Lib.reviews, which also requires an invitation to participate.

Conversely, we decided to leverage an already established user base of 40 million: Bluesky and its ATProto protocol. The idea is very simple: each user can use applications that write data into their online user account.

While Bluesky is establishing itself as the alternative to X, the latter has sunk in France below... Dailymotion !

Bluesky is a micro-blogging platform used to publish short texts of up to 300 characters. It is the most serious alternative to the fascist platform X.

On cartes.app, we simply attach these short texts to a place rather than to a news feed!

Your reviews belong to you

On Bluesky, I log in with my handle and every published message is written into my account. On cartes.app, I log in with the same handle and my reviews are written into my account.

I own the data of this account: by default this account is created on Bluesky's servers, a US company, but in a few clicks I can transfer it to another server, for example the European instance Eurosky where you can already pre-register.

For now Bluesky is the dominant instance of the AT protocol, but Eurosky is coming soon

Update: Eurosky has arrived! The network equivalent to Bluesky.app is called https://mu.social, it's a European Bluesky, fully connected to the American Bluesky. But Eurosky is above all a platform: a single account, a whole host of apps that replace TikTok, Instagram, Medium, Substack, etc.

What mattered to us was not asking our users to create yet another account. We could have based our review system on Mastodon, but the implementation would have been more complicated due to the Mastodon's choices.

In any case, Mastodon compatibility could be added later by a motivated developer, building on the foundations already laid.

What if I don't have a Bluesky or Eurosky account? Granted, you'll have to create one. But this account will give you access to a whole bunch of services, from creating a personal blog to reviewing movies or books, not to mention an alternative to Instagram or Facebook events.

Thus, you get the simplicity of the single Google account (a centralizing simplicity that FranceConnect did not choose) but owning your data, movable at will to another server and reusable by competing services. This galaxy has a name: the atmosphere, from the name of the protocol (ATProto) and the blue sky.

The only constraint is that everything you publish with your account will be public. For our topic of reviews, this is not a limitation, it's an advantage: your subjective review can just as easily advertise a business as harm it, so the review's author is identifiable.

Update: the first of december, a new version of the atmosphere will let apps create private data. Cartes.app will be able to write data to your account (e.g. your bookmarks) and it will only be readable by other apps, but they will need to ask your permission first. It's called Spaces.

Of course, if you prefer not to link your existing public profile and your reviews, you can simply create a second anonymous Bluesky account! A leading political figure, for example, may not want to share their appreciation of the intimate places they happen to frequent.

Contributing to OpenStreetMap or leaving reviews?

You may have noticed: it was already possible to log into cartes.app with your OpenStreetMap account to edit places: add opening hours, change the name or description of a café. So why another account to leave a review?

Simply because OpenStreetMap only accepts facts, not opinions. A café's opening hours are a fact, a neutral observation. The sequence of the Eckmühl Lighthouse is less useful to the general public, but remains a technical fact.

Conversely, your opinion on the butter soup at your local bistro is mainly subjective. It therefore has no place on OpenStreetMap, but it still has every chance of being useful to someone looking for a good vegetarian restaurant. Whether we like the concept of place reviews or not, we have to admit that they are sometimes very useful, often for the factual information they distill.

This comment doesn't add much factual information. Yet it confirms that the place still exists, and that at least one person likes it!

Indeed, it wouldn't be very intuitive for a user to add "butter soup: yes" in the restaurant's OpenStreetMap tags. In fact, the OpenStreetMap community might even reject such a level of detail.

Conversely, writing a comment that won't be displayed at the top of the place but further down, accessible via a search engine, will inform us more subtly. Same for the presence of bed bugs in a hotel or a comment about the temporary closure of an establishment.

Note that there is a risk that a user will give in to the ease of prose rather than contributing facts to OpenStreetMap, for example to report the closure of a place: it's not a big deal, because the license and date of comments allow their use by OpenStreetMap contributors to consolidate the place record from reviews. This is already the role of OpenStreetMap notes.

Note: we could have used the OpenStreetMap account rather than Bluesky to authenticate the user, but that would have required us to create our own database of subjective reviews. Conversely, with Bluesky, the data is not at cartes.app, but in the instances of the atmosphere, reusable by anyone.

Everything is fake?

As we mentioned in our founding article, "everything is fake" about online reviews, as the journalist showed who managed to rank a completely invented restaurant as London's top restaurant, whose whipped cream on the food photos was shaving foam.

Mmmmh 😋

Yep, this fictional restaurant ended up ranked first on Tripadvisor !

Reviews on big platforms are often biased or corrupted because the stakes for businesses to have a tenth of a point more than the competitor are enormous.

No rating, less cheating

To do better, we decided not to allow rating of a place. The user's appreciation is to be found in the nuance of their comment, or in the photos they publish, not in a one-dimensional score that will often be the only information retained as an average out of 5 displayed prominently in search results. This avoids the pitfall of what is called "American-style rating": below 4, it's bad, above 4.8 it's excellent.

We also avoid the bias of mixing value-for-money ratings on one side and absolute-quality ratings on the other. For a bourgeois used to 4-star restaurants, a neighborhood bistro whose lunch menu is €12 might be rated 1/5, when it would top 5/5 for an ordinary person who weighs quality against cost.

We also avoid the Instagram tourism effect in business ratings: a local restaurant beloved by residents can be completely overshadowed by a pizzeria whose burrata and ambiance are designed to please an audience that arrived by plane and is over-represented in the place's reviews.

Many locals love their neighborhood restaurant and go back every week without feeling the need to rate it, far from the modern frenzy decried in the famous episode "Nosedive" of the renowned series Black Mirror which explores the pitfalls of modern technologies.

In the Nosedive fiction, people rate everything, from the restaurant to their... office colleague

In the future, we will consider adding rating criteria of the type "👍️ I recommend" or "👎️ I don't recommend", accessory, non-numeric.

Moreover, our choice to base the review system on a social network will allow us to make it more reliable: to fight bots, we will be able to hide accounts that are too recent or suspicious. We will be able to use the moderation tools designed for other applications in the atmosphere.

Of course, reviews are governed by terms of use and we will be vigilant about unwanted content.

Open reviews

Right now, you can browse the feed of reviews published on Cartes.app. As of January 5, 2025, you'll notice there aren't many yet, but it's growing. A researcher can already download all the reviews.

Test Cartes✏️ Signaler une erreur

Nos derniers articles

  1. Publié le 26 octobre 2026
  2. Publié le 12 octobre 2026
  3. Publié le 1 septembre 2026
  4. Publié le 2 juin 2026
  5. Publié le 20 avril 2026
  6. Publié le 19 mars 2026
  7. Publié le 9 mars 2026
  8. Publié le 28 décembre 2025
  9. Publié le 21 juillet 2025
  10. Publié le 12 février 2025
  11. Publié le 7 janvier 2025
  12. Publié le 15 septembre 2024
  13. Publié le 2 septembre 2024
  14. Publié le 8 août 2024
  15. Publié le 22 juillet 2024
  16. Publié le 1 avril 2024
  17. Publié le 3 janvier 2024
  18. Publié le 1 décembre 2023
  19. Publié le 16 novembre 2023
  20. Publié le 11 novembre 2023
  21. Publié le 10 novembre 2023